On a night when 18 Champions League matches kicked off at the exact same time and Europe held its breath, Americans didn’t just show up – they mattered.
The final day of the 2025–26 Champions League league stage delivered drama everywhere you looked, and right in the middle of it was Malik Tillman. The 23-year-old attacking midfielder put on a statement performance for Bayer Leverkusen, scoring twice in a commanding 3–0 home win over Villarreal and reminding everyone that U.S. players are no longer passengers in Europe’s elite competition.
Tillman was electric from the opening whistle. In the 12th minute, he hunted down Villarreal goalkeeper Arnau Tenas inside the six-yard box, poking the ball into the net after a forced clearance. Twenty-three minutes later, he struck again – unleashing a vicious half-volley from the top of the penalty area that left no doubt. Two goals. One massive night. And a Champions League race tilted by an American.
Those goals marked Tillman’s first in the competition since November 2024, when he was still with PSV Eindhoven, and they couldn’t have come at a better time. His club advanced, and so did his reputation.
Across the continent, five clubs featuring U.S. men’s national team World Cup contenders survived the chaos and booked spots in the knockout phase. None cracked the top eight – which would’ve earned a direct bye – but Malik Tillman, Weston McKennie (Juventus), Johnny Cardoso (Atlético Madrid), Yunus Musah (Atalanta), and Folarin Balogun (Monaco) are all headed to the two-leg playoff round set for Feb. 17–18 and Feb. 24–25. The draw arrives Friday, and the bracket is already taking shape.
Not everyone made it through.
Sergiño Dest and PSV Eindhoven were bounced after a narrow 2–1 home loss to Bayern Munich, a result that dropped PSV all the way to 28th in the standings. Tim Weah’s Champions League journey ended in heartbreak. Marseille was eliminated on goal differential after Benfica goalkeeper Anatoliy Trubin – yes, the goalkeeper – headed in a free kick deep into stoppage time to seal a 4–2 win over Real Madrid. Had that match ended 3–2, Marseille would’ve advanced. Instead, Weah’s club paid the price for a brutal 3–0 loss earlier in Belgium to Club Brugge.
Weah logged all 90 minutes in his sixth Champions League start, but it wasn’t enough.
One of the night’s most intriguing matchups featured Americans on both sides. McKennie and Balogun went the distance in a scoreless draw, halting hot streaks for both players. McKennie saw his run of goals in three straight Champions League matches snapped, while Balogun’s two-game scoring drought followed three consecutive games on the scoresheet.
Elsewhere, Yunus Musah made his first Champions League start in more than four months but was subbed off early in the second half as Atalanta fell 1–0 at Union Saint-Gilloise. Johnny Cardoso came off the bench in the 64th minute for Atlético Madrid during a surprising 2–1 home loss to Norway’s Bodø/Glimt.
Beyond the Champions League spotlight, more Americans are shaping Europe’s postseason picture. In the Europa League, U.S. midfielder Tanner Tessmann and league-leading Lyon will try to clinch the top seed when they host PAOK. Meanwhile, center back Auston Trusty and Celtic are clinging to the final knockout spot ahead of a must-win home clash with Utrecht.
Taken together, the message is clear: the U.S. isn’t just producing players who reach Europe anymore – it’s producing players who influence outcomes. On a night when margins were razor-thin and pressure was sky-high, Americans left fingerprints all over the Champions League.
About the Author
