A public family feud has erupted over one of America’s most iconic candy brands after Brad Reese, grandson of H. B. Reese, accused The Hershey Company of quietly downgrading ingredients in several popular Reese’s products.
The allegations — which have gone viral on LinkedIn and triggered sharp responses from relatives — raise bigger questions for consumers: Have classic Reese’s products changed? What’s the difference between real chocolate and compound coating? And should shoppers be paying closer attention to labels?
Here’s what we know.
What Brad Reese Is Alleging
Brad Reese, 70, claims Hershey has:
- Replaced milk chocolate with compound coating made from vegetable oils
- Swapped real peanut butter for “peanut butter–flavored creme”
- Reduced quality while keeping prices the same
- Shrunk product sizes
“I’m really embarrassed as a member of the Reese family,” Reese said, arguing the changes reflect corporate cost-cutting rather than consumer demand.
He specifically pointed to products such as:
- Reese’s White Chocolate Cups
- Fast Break
- Take5
- Nutrageous
- Reese’s Sticks
He claims some now use coatings that contain enough vegetable oil that they would not qualify as “real chocolate” under certain food labeling standards.
Hershey’s Response
The Hershey Company denied altering the original Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups recipe, stating:
The original Peanut Butter Cups are still made with peanut butter and milk chocolate.
However, the company acknowledged “recipe adjustments” in new products, saying those changes allow innovation in shapes, sizes, and formats.
Notably, the company did not explicitly deny ingredient variations in all specialty or seasonal products.
The Labeling Question: Chocolate vs. Compound Coating
At the center of the debate is an important technical distinction:
Real Chocolate
Under U.S. Food and Drug Administration standards, chocolate must contain cocoa butter as the primary fat source.
Compound Coating (or “Creme”)
These products substitute vegetable oils (such as palm kernel oil) for cocoa butter. They are cheaper, easier to mold, and more shelf-stable — but technically different from chocolate.
That’s why consumers may see terms like:
- “White Creme” instead of “White Chocolate”
- “Peanut Butter Creme” instead of “Peanut Butter”
These labeling differences are legally significant.
The Viral LinkedIn Fallout
Reese’s online posts criticizing the company reportedly triggered backlash within his own family. His cousin, Becky Hilgers — whose daughter works for Hershey — allegedly texted him urging him to stop, warning that his statements could affect stock price and potentially create legal risk.
Hershey stock dipped about 0.9% following the controversy before recovering.
Hilgers countered that Reese is being “spiteful” and questioned how closely he’s followed production practices in recent decades.
The dispute has evolved into both a corporate transparency debate and a family conflict over legacy and reputation.
The Valentine’s Day “Breaking Point”
Reese says his tipping point came after purchasing Valentine’s Day “Unwrapped Chocolate Peanut Butter Creme Mini Hearts,” which he claims were inedible.
The product naming — particularly the use of “creme” — has fueled his argument that ingredient downgrades are being masked through subtle wording.
On Hershey’s website and retailers like Walmart, shoppers can find similarly labeled items such as:
- “White Creme Peanut Butter Easter Eggs”
- “Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Creme Eggs”
The wording varies by product line.
Bigger Picture: Are Candy Companies Cutting Costs?
This controversy lands at a time when:
- Cocoa prices have surged globally
- Food manufacturers face inflation pressure
- “Shrinkflation” concerns dominate consumer conversations
Switching to compound coatings can significantly reduce costs and improve manufacturing efficiency — especially for seasonal or specialty products.
But the reputational risk is substantial when heritage brands are involved.
Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, created by H. B. Reese in the 1920s, built their identity on a specific flavor balance between chocolate and peanut butter. Any perceived deviation touches brand loyalty at its core.
What Consumers Should Do
If you’re concerned about ingredient quality:
- Read ingredient lists carefully. Look for cocoa butter vs. vegetable oils.
- Check whether products say “chocolate” or “creme.”
- Compare seasonal vs. standard products — formulations may differ.
- Watch portion sizes as well as ingredients.
The original Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups remain widely sold as milk chocolate and peanut butter products, according to Hershey.
Why This Matters
This isn’t just a family dispute — it’s about:
- Food transparency
- Labeling clarity
- Brand trust
- Corporate cost-cutting strategies
Consumers today are more ingredient-aware than ever. Viral claims — especially from someone carrying the Reese name — amplify scrutiny quickly.
Whether this controversy fades or sparks broader consumer examination of candy labeling, one thing is clear:
When it comes to beloved legacy brands, even small wording changes can ignite big debates.
Final Take
For now, Hershey maintains its flagship Reese’s cups are unchanged. Brad Reese insists quality has slipped in key products.
The truth may lie in product-by-product nuance — and in consumers taking a closer look at what’s printed on the back of the package.
Because in 2026, brand loyalty alone isn’t enough. Ingredients matter.
About the Author
